Who has the Lowest ERA for the Mets?

For generations Earned Run Average (ERA) has been used to measure a pitcher’s effectiveness. While more recently ERA+ and Fielding Independent Pitching (FIP) have gained favor. Both attempt to remove the effects of external factors like ballparks, opponents or fielding to “normalize” the statistic.

But let’s stay old-school and look at pitcher’s ERA. Who is atop the leader board for the best ERA for the Mets in a single season?

Lowest ERA in a Mets Season

Mets PitcherYearERA
Jesse Orosco19831.47
Dwight Gooden19851.53
Jacob deGrom
Tug McGraw
Tug McGraw
Tom Seaver19711.76
Jerry Koosman
Tom Seaver
Tom Seaver19682.20
Tom Seaver19692.21

Lefty reliever Jesse Orosco has the lowest ERA in a Mets season. In 1983 Orosco’s ERA was just 1.47. Appearing in 62 games, Orosco went 13-7 with 17 saves. He threw 110 innings, giving up just 76 hits and 38 walks while striking out 84 batters. Jesse’s ERA+ that year was 248 and FIP was 2.65. The Mets finished last with a 68-94 record.

Jesse  Orosco pitching

If there were any justice in the world, Dwight Gooden would wear the single-season Mets ERA crown. In 1985 Gooden pitched an NL leading 276 innings, going 24-7. His 1.53 ERA also led the league that year. As did his 16 complete games, 268 strikeouts, 229 ERA+, and 2.13 FIP. He was the unanimous winner of the Cy Young award.

Related: When Jacob deGrom struck out the first 8 batters in a game.

Pitchers, especially relievers, can have one great year followed by a fall into obscurity. So what about over an entire Mets career? Who has the best ERA in a Mets career?

Lowest ERA in Mets History

Mets PitcherCareer ERA
Tom Seaver2.57
Jacob deGrom2.62
Jesse Orosco2.73
R.A. Dickey2.95
Jon Matlack3.03
Jerry Koosman3.09
John Franco
Dwight Gooden
Bob Ojeda3.12
David Cone3.13

Tom Seaver has the lowest ERA in New York Mets franchise history. Seaver had a 2.57 ERA while pitching 12 years for the Mets. Seaver totaled 3045 innings as a Met, with a 136 ERA+ and 2.67 FIP. In his entire 20-year career Seaver had a 2.86 ERA, with a 127 ERA+ and 3.04 FIP. Tom Terrific indeed.

Related: Gooden breaks the rookie strikeout record.

Jacob deGrom is in second place on the Mets All-Time ERA leader board. Over his 6 years of pitching for the Mets, deGrom owns a 2.62 ERA in 1101 innings. His ERA+ is 148 and has a 2.78 FIP. There is no shame in being second to Seaver.